Robotic vs. Traditional "open" Cystectomy with Neobladder

1 year 2 months ago #61101 by sara.anne
One thing that we always urge patients facing life-changing surgeries or treatments such as cystectomy is to seek a second opinion and ask detailed questions of the surgeon they are considering.  Such questions include the availability of options such as robotic/open surgery and, in the case of a neobladder, how many the surgeon has done.  This is a complicated surgery and the success is very dependent on the surgeon's experience and expertise.  

Unfortunately, a "one-size-fits-all" medical setting such as the one you belong to would probably NOT pay for this, nor do you have the choice of going elsewhere without paying for it.  Radical cystectomy is a VERY expensive surgery.

Sara Anne

Diagnosis 2-08 Small papillary TCC; CIS
BCG; BCG maintenance
Vice-President, American Bladder Cancer Society
Forum Moderator
The following user(s) said Thank You: VinceD

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 year 2 months ago #61100 by VinceD
My cancer recently progressed from CIS T0 to T1 (first diagnosed in 2017). I have had 24 total BCG treatment, and failed treatment twice. My doctor and the oncologists have recommended cystectomy, as the general consensus is that simply moving to chemotherapy is akin to kicking the can down the road, with the potential to be worse later on. I spoke with a one of my in-laws whose nephew is a professor of oncology at UW-Madison and she passed along my history to him. He also agreed that cystectomy is the route to go at this point. I have also had my second staging biopsy (standard practice is to do another biopsy prior to surgery) and it confirmed the T1 diagnosis. The good news is that it hasn't metastasized outside of the bladder, so long term prognosis is very good if the bladder is removed.  

They scheduled my surgery for January 25th. When I had the initial call to schedule my meeting with my surgeon, I asked if the surgery was going to be performed robotically or laparoscopically? The scheduler did not know and kicked the question back to my urologist, who later informed me that since I opted for a neobladder it could only be done as an open surgery (neither robotically or laparoscopic). I am a patient with Kaiser Permanente in Portland, OR. From what I have seen on line, it appears that robotic surgery, even for cystoscopy with neobladder, is pretty common.  I have seen one study, completed in 2018 that showed the outcomes for cystectomy robotic vs. Traditional are quite similar, the only difference being that cystectomy done robotically heals faster with much less blood loss. 

I asked my urologist for a referral to OHSU, but he is telling me he can't do that since Kaiser can offer treatment. I realize I am running short on time, but I would still like to explore options, does anyone have any advice?

Thanks, Vince

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Cynthiaeddieksara.anne