That is a tough one. When I developed into Stage 2, my Uro said I could try radiation. But he also said if the radiation failed there were no other options. I guess that was because of the damage to the intestines which would result and they would not be useful for reconstruction. In any event, it sounds like radiation was successful in your case. That doesn't mean it can't return, and I imagine that is why the Drs are saying to remove. I kind of wonder why they would radiate if they knew it would have to be removed anyway. Who could recommend in a case like this? All I can say is that better safe than sorry, and the Drs are recommending removal and I would remove. I had my RC 2 years ago this month, just had my 2nd year scan and am clear. Thank God. I had an ilial conduit and it has worked fine, no cathing, no voiding problems, et cet. But everyone has to make their own decision. Best of luck.